Beyond the Molecule

Beyond the Molecule

Beyond the Molecule

I recently visited PI Health Sciences Ltd. at Genome Valley, Hyderabad, at the invitation of my long-standing friend, Dr. S. Chandrasekhar, who joined the organisation as Chief Scientific Advisor after his superannuation as Secretary, Department of Science and Technology, Government of India. Given the freedom to choose my subject, I decided to speak on From Molecules to Missions, and, building upon my continuing engagement with artificial intelligence, made Science Beyond Silos in the AI Era my theme.

The conference room, with a capacity of about a hundred, was filled to capacity. Scientists from PI Health Sciences facilities at Panoli, Jaipur, Ankleshwar and Udaipur joined online. For a non-chemist to stand before such a formidable gathering of chemists was initially a little awkward for an engineer like me.

I therefore began with engineering.

Chemistry, I said, cannot remain in the flask. For a chemical reaction conceived by a scientist to become an industrial reality, engineering must create and control the required temperature, pressure, flow, mixing, separation and containment—precisely, repeatedly and safely. That simple acknowledgement produced an instant bonhomie. I could then change tracks and make the larger point: in the modern world, chemistry cannot remain separated from engineering, biology, environmental science, medicine—and increasingly, AI.

The hour then passed like a breeze.

Using AI-generated slides, I began with a proposition that sounds almost philosophical but is fundamentally scientific: molecules have an afterlife. What we create does not simply vanish after its intended use is over. Molecules may degrade, transform, bind to other substances, migrate, accumulate or persist. Their journey can continue long after the product they were designed for has been discarded.

Consider the chemicals entering soil through fertilisers, herbicides and pesticides; industrial chemicals discharged onto land and water; or pharmaceuticals and their metabolites leaving the human body and entering sewage systems. Some are removed or broken down, but others can survive treatment, move through water and soil, interact with organisms and reappear in unexpected places.

What goes down does not simply go away.

Groundwater makes this particularly clear. Landfill leachate, industrial effluents and agricultural chemicals can migrate through soil and rock and, under the wrong conditions, reach aquifers. Once there, the problem is no longer one of chemistry alone. Hydrology must tell us where the water moves. Geology determines the pathways. Agriculture must examine uptake by crops. Toxicology and medicine must assess exposure and consequences. Public policy must decide acceptable risk levels and how best to prevent or mitigate the associated harms.

The food web carries the story further. Certain persistent pollutants can accumulate in organisms and, in some cases, become increasingly concentrated at higher trophic levels. What begins invisibly in water may pass into plankton, fish, larger predators and ultimately human beings. The food web remembers what our production and disposal systems may forget.

Then there is plastic.

Plastic is one of modern chemistry’s great achievements precisely because it is durable, versatile and inexpensive. Yet the durability that created its enormous utility has also created its environmental persistence. Larger plastic objects fragment into microplastics and still smaller particles; fragmentation is not disappearance. Such particles are now found across marine and terrestrial environments and have been detected in human tissues as well. The precise health consequences are still being investigated, and science should resist premature claims. But the ubiquity of exposure itself gives us sufficient reason to take prevention, materials design and waste management far more seriously than we presently do.

This led me to a more uncomfortable question. Have we built parts of modern civilisation in which we first create exposures and lifestyles that favour chronic disease and then build increasingly sophisticated systems to treat their consequences?

The diabetes epidemic, for example, cannot be attributed simply to sugar—humans have consumed sugars for millennia. But it certainly cannot be separated from the modern ability to refine, concentrate, manufacture and distribute calorie-dense foods on an unprecedented scale, combined with sedentary living and other metabolic risks. Similarly, rising concern about environmental exposures and cancers in younger populations deserves rigorous investigation, not sensational attribution to a single culprit. The scientific responsibility is to ask the question early enough, collect the right evidence and act when the evidence becomes persuasive.

The same principle applies to climate change. Carbon capture is scientifically feasible and has already been demonstrated in several settings. But capturing carbon dioxide is only one part of the problem. It must then be compressed, transported and stored securely for very long periods. Economics, infrastructure, geology, monitoring, regulation and public confidence immediately enter the picture. Once again, no discipline owns the problem.

This was the central message of my lecture.

Plastic pollution is not merely polymer chemistry. Groundwater contamination is not merely hydrology. Food safety is not merely biology. Climate change is not merely atmospheric science. The problems have already crossed the boundaries between our departments. Our science must now do the same.

And this is where AI offers an extraordinary opportunity.

AI’s greatest contribution to science may not ultimately be faster calculation. It may be its ability to connect what science has separated—datasets residing in different institutions, models built by different disciplines, research literature too vast for one individual to master, and relationships visible only when information is examined across scales.

Chemistry can speak to biology. Environmental measurements can connect with health outcomes. Molecular properties can be combined with hydrology and land-use data to predict environmental fate. AI-enabled surveillance can identify emerging contamination hotspots, detect weak signals and help us move from discovering damage after it has occurred to anticipating pathways before harm becomes widespread.

In other words, from prediction to prevention.

That requires a change in the scientist’s question. We must continue asking, Does this molecule work? But we should add: Where will it eventually go? What will it become? What will it encounter? And what might it do there?

We must begin to design for fate, not merely for function.

After the lecture and an engaging Q&A, we continued the conversation over an excellent working lunch. It gave me an opportunity to interact more closely with Dr. Dinesh Chaurasiya, Dr. Prathama Mainkar and Dr. Abhishek Sud, among other outstanding scientists who have helped build PI into a leading Contract Research, Development and Manufacturing Organisation, particularly in the agrochemical domain. Their depth of scientific experience and the range of the discussion reinforced the very point I had tried to make in my lecture: important problems are increasingly solved not within disciplinary compartments, but through conversations across them.

Dr. Chandrasekhar, with his trademark wit, provided the perfect closing line. “Karl Ziegler and Giulio Natta received the 1963 Nobel Prize in Chemistry for their discoveries in the chemistry and technology of high polymers”, he said. “Now depolymerisation is waiting for one. Whoever really gets rid of plastics may take it home.”

Behind the humour lies a serious mission.

The scientist’s responsibility does not end when the molecule succeeds. It extends to what that molecule eventually does in the world.

Our molecules. Our missions. Our world. Our responsibility.

I returned home with a quiet sense of fulfilment—almost like a pilgrim returning from a place of learning and purpose. PI Health Sciences had seemed to me not merely a laboratory or an enterprise, but a portal of scientific excellence, where knowledge is being transformed into possibilities for a better world.

 

MORE FROM THE BLOG

Beyond the Molecule

Beyond the Molecule

I recently visited PI Health Sciences Ltd. at Genome Valley, Hyderabad, at the invitation of my long-standing friend, Dr. S. Chandrasekhar, who joined the organisation as Chief Scientific Advisor after his superannuation as Secretary, Department of Science and...

Nataraja: Metallurgy in Motion

Nataraja: Metallurgy in Motion

Among the great images created by Indian civilisation, few possess the visual authority of the Chola Nataraja. Shiva dances within a circle of flame, one foot planted upon ignorance and the other lifted in liberating grace. His hair flies outward, his arms extend in...

Salt, Spice and Time

Salt, Spice and Time

Recently, I had the pleasure of attending a family dinner hosted by Vishal Arora, a young CEO and a friend of my son Amol. His wife’s parents were also present. Although they all come from New Delhi, they seemed to carry with them something of the city’s older...

Nataraja: Metallurgy in Motion

Nataraja: Metallurgy in Motion

Nataraja: Metallurgy in Motion

Among the great images created by Indian civilisation, few possess the visual authority of the Chola Nataraja. Shiva dances within a circle of flame, one foot planted upon ignorance and the other lifted in liberating grace. His hair flies outward, his arms extend in several directions, yet his face remains serenely composed. Motion and stillness, destruction and renewal are held together in one form. It is not merely a god dancing, but a philosophical account of a universe continuously becoming, dissolving and beginning again.

The Chola Nataraja is also remarkable as a product of metal engineering. The sculptor had to transform an extraordinarily complex wax model—with extended arms, slender fingers, flying locks, flames, ornaments and an asymmetrically positioned body—into a durable copper-alloy image. Molten metal had to flow into every extremity before solidifying; the mould had to preserve minute details while containing the molten alloy; and the finished sculpture had to remain stable despite appearing to balance on a single dancing foot.

The precise construction method varied with the idol’s size and design. In some monumental examples, Shiva, the dwarf Apasmara, an icon of spiritual ignorance, ego, and forgetfulness of one’s true divine nature, and the flaming aureole were solid-cast together, while the lotus pedestal and rectangular plinth were cast separately and mechanically attached. What appears to the observer as a single, effortless composition could therefore be a carefully planned assembly of cast and joined components.

The engineering began long before the furnace was lit. The figure was constructed according to a canonical system of proportion in which the body was divided into modules that regulated the dimensions of the head, torso, limbs, hands, and overall stature. These proportions were not merely aesthetic conventions. They also controlled the length, position and mass of projecting components.

The raised leg extends across the body, four arms spread into the surrounding space, and locks of hair radiate from the head. If these elements were disproportionately long or heavy, they would increase the bending moments acting at the ankles, shoulders, wrists and hair junctions. Proportional geometry therefore helped the sculptor reconcile visual dynamism with physical stability.

In the living bronze-casting tradition of Swamimalai, the wax mixture has commonly been prepared from approximately equal proportions of beeswax and powdered dammar resin, softened with a small quantity of groundnut or sesame oil. Beeswax provides plasticity; the resin increases firmness and helps the model retain sharp edges; and the oil modifies its workability. The result is a modelling material that can be shaped by hand while remaining sufficiently stable to hold intricate detail.

Wax channels were then attached to the model. Some became pouring passages, or sprues, while others formed runners that distributed molten metal towards distant or delicate regions. Traditional prescriptions and surviving workshop practices often place these channels at the back, shoulders, neck and head, where the marks left after their removal would be least disruptive.

Their position was critical. Insufficient feeding could leave a hand, finger or flame incomplete. Poorly arranged passages could create excessive turbulence, trap gases or cause separate streams of metal to meet only after they had cooled too far to fuse properly. The channels therefore had to deliver metal rapidly and evenly while allowing displaced air and gases to escape.

The clay mould had to perform several apparently conflicting functions. Its inner surface needed to be fine enough to reproduce delicate facial modelling and ornament. At the same time, it had to be porous enough to release gases, refractory enough to withstand contact with molten copper alloy and mechanically strong enough to resist cracking or bursting during the pour.

The principal constituent of most early South Indian bronze images was copper, often forming around four-fifths or more of the alloy. Tin and lead were present in varying proportions, while zinc, silver, gold and other metals might occur in smaller or even trace quantities. The ritual term pancha-loha, meaning ‘five metals’, should therefore not be understood as a single, universally fixed metallurgical formula.

Tin increases copper’s hardness and strength, although excessive tin can make the alloy brittle. Lead has only limited solubility in copper and tends to remain dispersed as small globules, but it can improve the apparent fluidity and castability of the molten alloy. It may therefore help the metal enter narrow passages and reproduce fine details.

Yet some outstanding bronzes contain relatively modest quantities of both tin and lead. Their successful casting depended not merely upon a highly fluid alloy, but upon the entire foundry system: careful mould preparation, accurate temperature control, intelligent gating and rapid, well-directed pouring.

A Nataraja is especially difficult to cast because its sections vary greatly in thickness. The massive torso retains heat and remains molten longer than the slender fingers, flying hair and individual flames. If these thin regions solidify before they have filled completely, the result is a misrun—an incomplete casting. If two partly cooled streams meet, they may produce a cold shut, a weak seam where the metal fronts fail to fuse fully.

Thicker sections created additional challenges because metal contracts as it cools. Without continued feeding from reservoirs of molten alloy, shrinkage cavities, gas porosity, residual stresses, cracking and distortion could develop. The mould and gating system therefore had to ensure rapid filling of delicate features followed by progressive solidification, keeping heavier regions supplied with liquid metal long enough to compensate for contraction. The sculptor-founder was controlling not only the bronze’s form, but also the sequence in which it became solid.

The structural achievement is equally impressive. Visually, Shiva appears to float upon one leg. Mechanically, however, the load is distributed through a more complex system. The principal gravitational force passes through the supporting leg, the figure of Apasmara, the footplate and the pedestal. The entire geometry of the dancing Shiva is composed around this gravitational axis: although the limbs, hair and surrounding aureole extend dramatically into space, their masses counterbalance one another so precisely that the sculpture’s combined centre of gravity is brought into alignment with the single supporting leg. What appears to be movement at the edge of instability is, in fact, a remarkable achievement of static balance.

The Nataraja is therefore not a statue precariously balanced upon a single point of support. It is a carefully integrated structural system that conceals its engineering within its iconography. Apasmara becomes a compression-bearing element; the lotus pedestal becomes a load-distributing foundation; hair and ornamental links act as braces; and the aureole helps unite the composition mechanically as well as visually.

Chola craftsmen did not possess modern phase diagrams, finite-element models or computational fluid-dynamics software. Their knowledge was embodied in measurements, materials, proportions, workshop sequences and accumulated experience. A failed finger indicated inadequate feeding. A cracked investment revealed unsuitable clay, excessive moisture or insufficient drying. Porosity could indicate trapped gases, turbulence or inadequate control of the melt.

Over generations, success and failure produced a systematic body of empirical knowledge, transmitted through apprenticeship and grounded in close observation, disciplined practice and an intimate understanding of materials. This tradition remains alive in Swamimalai, where master sculptors and bronze casters from hereditary craft families continue to create sacred images through the lost-wax process, preserving historic proportions, materials and foundry techniques.

The continuing capacity of this tradition was dramatically demonstrated by the Nataraja installed at Bharat Mandapam for the 2023 G20 Summit in New Delhi. Standing 27 feet high including the pedestal and weighing approximately 18 tonnes, it was produced by traditional master craftsmen from Swamimalai using lost-wax casting and canonical proportions. Its scale was modern, but the fundamental sequence—proportional design, wax modelling, refractory investment, dewaxing, alloy melting, pouring and hand finishing—continued the historic South Indian foundry tradition.

The Chola Nataraja is thus not simply bronze shaped into a beautiful deity. It is geometry translated into wax, wax transformed into a refractory void, and that void filled through the controlled movement of fire and molten metal. Its deepest engineering triumph lies in making immense technical difficulty disappear.

The observer sees neither sprues nor solidification fronts, neither shrinkage cavities nor hidden load paths. One sees only Shiva dancing—bronze transformed into rhythm, mass into apparent weightlessness, and metallurgical knowledge into spiritual form.

MORE FROM THE BLOG

Beyond the Molecule

Beyond the Molecule

I recently visited PI Health Sciences Ltd. at Genome Valley, Hyderabad, at the invitation of my long-standing friend, Dr. S. Chandrasekhar, who joined the organisation as Chief Scientific Advisor after his superannuation as Secretary, Department of Science and...

Nataraja: Metallurgy in Motion

Nataraja: Metallurgy in Motion

Among the great images created by Indian civilisation, few possess the visual authority of the Chola Nataraja. Shiva dances within a circle of flame, one foot planted upon ignorance and the other lifted in liberating grace. His hair flies outward, his arms extend in...

Salt, Spice and Time

Salt, Spice and Time

Recently, I had the pleasure of attending a family dinner hosted by Vishal Arora, a young CEO and a friend of my son Amol. His wife’s parents were also present. Although they all come from New Delhi, they seemed to carry with them something of the city’s older...

Salt, Spice and Time

Salt, Spice and Time

Salt, Spice and Time

Recently, I had the pleasure of attending a family dinner hosted by Vishal Arora, a young CEO and a friend of my son Amol. His wifes parents were also present. Although they all come from New Delhi, they seemed to carry with them something of the citys older culture—refinement in living, warmth in social relationships and a deep appreciation of food. We spent nearly four hours together, but the evening passed like a mild breeze.

As we were leaving, Vishal, who is also an accomplished chef by passion, presented me with a small glass jar of pickle. He invited me to choose from a remarkably wide variety that he had prepared and curated himself. I selected a dried raw-mango pickle seasoned prominently with black mustard seeds—rai in Hindi. It contained only a minimal quantity of mustard oil, used less as a heavy covering than as a medium for carrying the flavour and aroma of the spices.

Pickles are almost inseparable from Indian food. A small portion may accompany an otherwise simple meal of dal, rice, roti, curd or khichdi and transform its entire sensory character. Vishalspassionately curated collection made me reflect upon the considerable science concealed within this ordinary-looking food. A pickle is not merely a fruit or vegetable immersed in salt, oil and spices. It is a deliberately constructed biochemical environment in which water, acidity, oxygen, microbial life, plant enzymes and aromatic molecules are brought into a controlled relationship.

The first principle of pickling is the management of water. Fresh mango, lemon, chilli, carrot, radish, amla, garlic and most other vegetables contain enough available water to support the growth of bacteria, yeast and mould. Salt begins the preservation process through osmosis. When salt surrounds the plant tissue, water moves out of the cells towards the region of higher solute concentration. This produces the familiar brine that appears even when no water has been added. The removal and binding of water reduce its availability to microorganisms. At the same time, salt penetrates the plant tissue, changing its texture and creating conditions in which some organisms are inhibited while more salt-tolerant species may survive. Studies of vegetable fermentation show that salt concentration influences not only preservation but also the composition of the microbial community, the speed of fermentation and the final flavour. Excessive salt may inhibit even desirable fermentative organisms, while insufficient salt can permit spoilage microbes to dominate.

Drying, as in the mango pickle Vishal gave me, adds another layer of protection. Sun-drying or controlled dehydration removes a substantial part of the fruits moisture before it enters the jar. The biochemical reactions that require available water consequently slow down. Enzymes become less active, microbial multiplication becomes difficult, and the mango acquires a concentrated sourness and a resilient, chewy texture. Drying does not sterilise the fruit, but it makes the internal environment much less favourable to rapid decomposition.

Acidity is the second great principle. Raw mangoes and lemons naturally contain organic acids, while many recipes add vinegar or lemon juice. In genuinely fermented pickles, naturally occurring lactic acid bacteria metabolise sugars present in the fruit or vegetable and convert them largely into lactic acid. As acidity increases and the pH falls, many undesirable organisms are progressively excluded. Fermentation also creates new flavour molecules, which is why a fermented pickle tastes more complex than a vegetable merely dipped in vinegar. Traditional Indian pickles have yielded diverse lactic acid bacteria, yeasts and other microorganisms, demonstrating that the pickle jar can become a small, evolving ecosystem.

It is important, however, not to call every pickle fermented. Many Indian achaar preparations are preserved primarily through a combination of drying, salt, natural or added acid, spices and oil. Their purpose is to prevent microbial activity rather than encourage a controlled fermentation. Similarly, not every homemade pickle should automatically be described as probiotic. Researchers have isolated organisms with potentially beneficial properties from certain traditionally fermented mango pickles, but such findings relate to particular strains studied under defined conditions. Whether those organisms survive storage, remain present in sufficient numbers and withstand digestion must be demonstrated before a specific pickle can legitimately be regarded as probiotic.

Mustard seeds bring a small chemical drama to the pickle jar. Black and brown mustard contain sinigrin and an enzyme called myrosinase, which are stored separately within the seed. Crushing and moistening the seed brings them together, producing allyl isothiocyanate—the volatile compound that gives mustard its sharp, nose-clearing bite. It can also inhibit some bacteria and fungi, allowing rai to contribute both flavour and modest chemical protection. Yet it is only one part of the preservation system.

Mustard oil spreads spice aromas, coats the fruit or vegetable, and helps limit contact with air and moisture. The oil layer at the top of a jar also discourages surface contamination. But oil alone cannot preserve a wet, poorly salted or insufficiently acidic pickle. Safety and stability arise from several barriers working together: salt, acidity, reduced moisture, antimicrobial spices, limited oxygen and clean handling.

The glowing colours of Indian pickles are also products of chemistry. Turmeric owes its golden hue mainly to curcumin, a pigment that can also slow some oxidation reactions. In experimental studies on pickled cucumbers, turmeric reduced the formation of volatile aldehydes associated with oxidative deterioration. Chillies add red carotenoid pigments and capsaicinoids, the compounds responsible for their heat. Fenugreek, fennel, cumin, ajwain, ginger, garlic and asafoetida contribute their own essential oils, sulphur compounds, phenolics, bitters and aromatic molecules. Together, they create a rich flavour system: acids provide sourness, sodium ions saltiness, plant compounds bitterness, mustard and chilli pungency, and numerous volatile molecules the characteristic aroma.

Time then works quietly within the jar. Salt and acid move deeper into the mango, while spice compounds pass into the oil and plant tissue. Sharp individual flavours gradually blend and soften. Some aromas fade, new ones emerge, and the texture changes as cell membranes and cell-wall materials are altered. A freshly prepared pickle and a matured one may contain exactly the same ingredients, yet taste remarkably different. Maturation is therefore not merely waiting; it is a continuing series of physical and biochemical exchanges.

India also has a smaller but notable tradition of non-vegetarian pickles, particularly those made from fish and prawns in coastal and southern regions. The basic principles remain the same—thorough cooking, moisture reduction, salt, acid, spices and oil—but the chemistry is more demanding. Protein-rich foods can support microbial growth, while animal fats are vulnerable to oxidation and may develop rancid flavours. Careful cooking, scrupulous hygiene, minimal residual moisture and proper storage are therefore essential to the pickles safety, quality and shelf life.

Pickles are best enjoyed in modest quantities. Their concentrated salt, acidity, oil and pungency allow even a small spoonful to stimulate the appetite, sharpen flavours and provide a lively contrast to the rest of the meal. Larger quantities, however, may add excessive salt and oil while overpowering the food they are meant to complement.

The science of pickles offers a useful lesson about tradition. Traditional practice should neither be romanticised as infallible nor dismissed as primitive simply because its practitioners did not speak in the language of pH, water activity, osmotic pressure, glucosinolates or microbial ecology. Through generations of observation, households learned that mango must be dried, jars must remain clean, moisture must be controlled, salt must be sufficient, spices must be properly prepared, and the contents must be protected from air and contamination.

Science does not diminish this inheritance. It reveals its architecture. The jar that Vishal placed in my hands contained mango, mustard, salt, oil and spices—but it also contained osmotic gradients, organic acids, enzyme reactions, volatile antimicrobials, antioxidant molecules and the memory of countless domestic experiments. What appears at the table as a modest spoonful of achaar is, in reality, a beautifully balanced exercise in biochemistry.

MORE FROM THE BLOG

Beyond the Molecule

Beyond the Molecule

I recently visited PI Health Sciences Ltd. at Genome Valley, Hyderabad, at the invitation of my long-standing friend, Dr. S. Chandrasekhar, who joined the organisation as Chief Scientific Advisor after his superannuation as Secretary, Department of Science and...

Nataraja: Metallurgy in Motion

Nataraja: Metallurgy in Motion

Among the great images created by Indian civilisation, few possess the visual authority of the Chola Nataraja. Shiva dances within a circle of flame, one foot planted upon ignorance and the other lifted in liberating grace. His hair flies outward, his arms extend in...

Salt, Spice and Time

Salt, Spice and Time

Recently, I had the pleasure of attending a family dinner hosted by Vishal Arora, a young CEO and a friend of my son Amol. His wife’s parents were also present. Although they all come from New Delhi, they seemed to carry with them something of the city’s older...

Aggregating Compassion

Aggregating Compassion

Aggregating Compassion

A recent knowledge-sharing session titled CSR Meets the Social Stock Exchange: A Journey Ahead, organised by Equippp Social Impact Technologies Limited (EQUIPPP) and held at Yashoda Hospitals, Hyderabad, recently introduced me to Dr. Bhaskar Chatterjee, a veteran IAS officer, who played a pioneering role in shaping India’s Corporate Social Responsibility framework. The gathering represented a broad cross-section of the social development ecosystem.

Hosted by Dr. Chinnababu Sunkavalli, a robotic cancer surgeon and Founder of the GRACE Cancer Foundation, the programme marked the Foundation’s listing on the Social Stock Exchange. Dr. Chinnababu is also a valued friend, and I have long admired his sustained commitment to making cancer care and early detection accessible to underserved communities. What appeared to be a specialised financial event was, in fact, an important attempt to bring the discipline, transparency and accountability of capital markets into the service of social good.

The Social Stock Exchange addresses a familiar yet persistent problem. Compassion is abundant, but often fragmented. Individuals are willing to contribute, companies have CSR commitments, and social organisations possess valuable field experience. Yet these strengths do not always converge within a credible, transparent and scalable system. Whether donated funds are ultimately deployed for genuine, measurable social good often remains uncertain—an enigma at best and a serious concern at worst.

The term Social Stock Exchange, or SSE, can initially be confusing. A conventional stock exchange enables companies to raise capital and investors to seek financial returns by buying and selling shares. Are we now proposing to buy and sell charities? “No, no—a thousand times no! Nothing could be further from the truth,” one might say, borrowing the emphatic tone of Sherlock Holmes after eliminating the impossible.

India’s Social Stock Exchange (SSE) is a relatively recent institutional innovation. The Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) formally notified the regulatory framework on 25 July 2022, followed by the issuance of a detailed operational framework on 19 September 2022. The SSEoperates as a separate segment of a recognised stock exchange, enabling eligible social enterprises to register, make prescribed disclosures and raise funds within a regulated framework. Its most distinctive innovation is the Zero Coupon Zero Principal (ZCZP) instrument.

In an ordinary bond, the investor earns interest and expects the principal to be repaid at maturity. A Zero Coupon Zero Principal instrument is fundamentally different: it offers neither interest nor repayment of principal. The contributor provides funds for a clearly defined social purpose, and the return lies entirely in the social value created. Yet the instrument is issued within a regulated framework, supported by prescribed disclosures, reporting requirements and accountability. It may therefore be understood as a donation supported by the discipline of the capital market.

Consider a cancer foundation seeking ₹2 crore to operate mobile screening units in underserved districts. Under the traditional model, it may have to approach companies, charitable trusts and individual donors separately, preparing different proposals and complying with different reporting requirements. Funding may arrive irregularly, making it difficult to sustain a programme that depends on specialised equipment, trained personnel, digital data systems, diagnostic referrals and continuous patient follow-up. Such an undertaking requires not only generosity, but also a dependable funding pipeline.

Through the Social Stock Exchange, the foundation can present the programme as a clearly defined project, specifyingthe population to be covered, the personnel and equipment required, the duration, the budget, the referral pathway and the expected outcomes. It can then raise funds by issuing ZCZP instruments for that project. A company may contribute ₹50 lakh, a philanthropic institution ₹25 lakh, and numerous smaller contributors the balance. A mission beyond the capacity of any one donor can thus be supported collectively by many.

The contributors receive neither interest nor repayment, but they gain visibility into how the funds are used, whether the stated targets are achieved, how many suspected cases are identified and referred, and what measurable difference the programme makes. The exchange neither operates the screening units nor guarantees their success. Its role is to provide a transparent and regulated platform that connectsthose who possess resources  with organisations that have the experience and capacity to address social needs.

Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) enters the picture here. Under Section 135 of the Companies Act, 2013, qualifying companies are required to spend at least two per cent of their average net profits of the preceding three financial years on eligible CSR activities. On 27 May 2026, the Ministry of Corporate Affairs expanded this framework by recognising subscriptions to eligible ZCZP instruments listed on the Social Stock Exchange as permissible CSR expenditure. Companies may use this route for up to ten per cent of their total CSR expenditure in a financial year. The SSE does not replace conventional CSR; it provides an additional regulated channel through which companies can join other contributors in supporting clearly defined social projects.

The value of the SSE lies in four interconnected strengths: trust, visibility, aggregation and accountability. Registration and standardised disclosures establish a common threshold of transparency, allowing a credible social organisation—even one working in a remote district—to reach a much wider community of contributors.

Aggregation can be equally transformative. A public health, education, nutrition or livelihood programme may be beyond the capacity of any single contributor, yet entirely feasible when hundreds or thousands participate. Scattered streams of generosity can thus converge into a river capable of sustaininga major social mission.

Above all, the SSE shifts attention from expenditure to impact. Traditional philanthropy may sometimes measure success by the amount spent, the activities conducted or the number of people reached. The more demanding question is: What actually changed in the lives of the intended beneficiaries?

The central question is not how much money was spent, but what changed as a result. A training programme should be judged by whether participants acquired useful skills and improved their livelihoods. A cancer screening programme should track abnormal findings, referrals, confirmed diagnoses, treatment linkages and, ultimately, lives extended or saved. Data must show not merely that an activity took place, but whether it produced meaningful change. Digital systems and artificial intelligence (AI) can strengthen such accountability at scale.

The SSE should not, however, be romanticised. Listing on the exchange cannot guarantee social transformation. Smaller organisations may struggle with documentation and compliance, and not every valuable outcome can be reduced to a number. Dignity, confidence, solidarity and freedom from fear resist easy measurement. Funding must not therefore flow only to causes whose results are easiest to quantify.

People seek not only wealth, but also meaning. Wealth finds its deepest purpose when it creates a legacy that endures beyond one lifetime. The Social Stock Exchange offers a way to convert generosity into sustained social action by preserving purpose, measuring outcomes and building institutions that endure.

 

The listing of organisations such as Grace Cancer Foundation is therefore more than a financial milestone. It points to a new social compact in which corporations provide resources, civilsociety organisations contribute field experience, regulators foster trust and citizens participate in measurable public good. The SSE does not put a price on compassion. It gives compassion a platform, a structure and a means of demonstrating what it has achieved.

 

Grace Cancer Foundation’s dream of deploying 1,000 mobile screening buses across India’s hinterlands can now move closer to reality. Properly channelled, compassion can flow like rain across the countryside, reaching every field rather than only those with their own source of water.

 

Hats off to these aggregators of compassion. I have encountered few ideas in the social sector that appear so credible, hopeful and potentially transformative. When compassion is aggregated, organised and made accountable, it ceases to be an occasional act of charity and becomes a sustained force for social change.

MORE FROM THE BLOG

Beyond the Molecule

Beyond the Molecule

I recently visited PI Health Sciences Ltd. at Genome Valley, Hyderabad, at the invitation of my long-standing friend, Dr. S. Chandrasekhar, who joined the organisation as Chief Scientific Advisor after his superannuation as Secretary, Department of Science and...

Nataraja: Metallurgy in Motion

Nataraja: Metallurgy in Motion

Among the great images created by Indian civilisation, few possess the visual authority of the Chola Nataraja. Shiva dances within a circle of flame, one foot planted upon ignorance and the other lifted in liberating grace. His hair flies outward, his arms extend in...

Salt, Spice and Time

Salt, Spice and Time

Recently, I had the pleasure of attending a family dinner hosted by Vishal Arora, a young CEO and a friend of my son Amol. His wife’s parents were also present. Although they all come from New Delhi, they seemed to carry with them something of the city’s older...

Tea and the Art of Being

Tea and the Art of Being

Tea and the Art of Being

Recently, my son Amol brought me Ceylon tea from Sri Lanka, and my biomedical engineering pupil, Deepti Sai Prasad, presented me with an elegant Queen Elizabeth box of tea bags she brought from London. They could hardly have chosen a gift that would have delighted me more.

I love tea. Whenever I am asked, “Tea or coffee?”, my answer comes without a moment’s hesitation: “Tea.”

I grew up drinking tea. In my native Meerut, tea is not merely brewed; it is almost cooked. Strong black tea leaves—typically the robust Assam variety—are boiled vigorously with milk and generous quantities of sugar, with two teaspoons per cup being the norm. Ginger and cardamom are added as the mixture simmers, allowing their flavours to infuse the tea. The entire house becomes fragrant. Tea is not only consumed; it is announced.

Years later, after moving to Hyderabad, I encountered another marvel—Irani tea. It belongs to an altogether different tradition. A robust black tea blend, usually rich in Assam CTC leaves, is brewed into a concentrated decoction, while the milk is simmered separately for hours, developing a natural sweetness through gentle caramelisation. The two meet only at the moment of serving. The result is velvety, aromatic, and almost meditative—a cup that rewards patience as much as craftsmanship. A plate of Osmania biscuits, lightly dipped into the tea before each bite, completes the experience. It feels less like drinking tea than performing a small daily ritual of contentment.

That cup also awakened my curiosity. Every beverage carries not only a flavour but a civilisation. Behind its aroma lie journeys across continents, encounters between cultures, and centuries of commerce, conquest and adaptation. The more I reflected on tea, the more I realised that it is not merely a drink but one of history’s most remarkable travellers.

There is a great deal of history behind tea. Tea never grew naturally in England; the climate required for the evergreen shrub simply does not exist there. Tea is native to China, where it had been cultivated and cherished for centuries before Europe discovered its allure. Yet England became its most influential global promoter because it understood something larger than agriculture: a product can be culturally appropriated by those who control its trade, shape its image, and weave it into the fabric of everyday life.

The British East India Company played a decisive role in transforming tea from a Chinese luxury into a global commodity. It first imported tea on a vast scale and, when dependence on China became commercially inconvenient, encouraged the development of tea plantations in Assam, Darjeeling, the Nilgiris and Sri Lanka (formerly Ceylon). Yet Britain’s greatest achievement lay not in growing tea but in giving it a distinctive cultural identity. Through afternoon tea, fine porcelain, etiquette, conversation, and the rituals of domestic hospitality, tea came to symbolise refinement and social order. Carried by empire, commerce and literature, this distinctly British way of drinking tea spread across much of the world.

The English transformed tea from an agricultural product into a social institution. They refined not only its trade but also its preparation. Though the British did not invent tea drinking; they transformed it into a distinctive social ritual. Water is brought almost to the boil, loose leaves are allowed to infuse in a teapot, and warm milk is poured into the cup first—a practice said to have protected delicate porcelain from cracking—before adding the strained tea. The ritual possesses an elegance born of centuries of repetition.

Tea punctuates the English day. It begins with the first cup on waking and continues through breakfast, mid-morning, afternoon tea with sandwiches or scones, and the traditional late-afternoon gathering, usually at five o’clock. High tea, despite its aristocratic reputation, was originally the hearty evening meal of the working classes, served at a high dining table with substantial fare and tea. For many households, the day ends with yet another comforting cup.

The world of tea has its own aristocracy. Earl Grey, delicately scented with bergamot, is perhaps the most celebrated blend, while English Breakfast draws its strength from teas grown in Assam, Kenya and Sri Lanka. Darjeeling, cultivated on the mist-covered slopes of the Himalayas, is often called the ‘Champagne of teas’ for its floral aroma and muscatel notes. Ceylon teas are bright and brisk, Kenyan teas add colour and body, and Assam provides the rich malty depth that anchors many of the world’s favourite blends.

Exploring these varieties inevitably raises another question. If tea possesses such extraordinary diversity, why do so many people still reach instinctively for coffee? The two beverages occupy neighbouring places in our daily lives, yet they arrive at their flavours by remarkably different paths. Tea reveals the character of a leaf; coffee is transformed by fire. Hundreds of volatile aromatic compounds are formed as coffee beans are roasted at high temperatures, producing flavours ranging from chocolate and caramel to toasted nuts and smoke.

A fresh tea leaf contains several thousand naturally occurring chemical compounds. During withering, rolling, oxidation (often called fermentation in the tea trade), and drying, these compounds rearrange themselves into an astonishing spectrum of aromas and flavours. Scientists have identified well over 600 volatile compounds that contribute to tea’s aroma, while thousands of other compounds influence its colour, taste, mouthfeel and potential health benefits. Polyphenols, such as catechins and theaflavins, contribute to tea’s antioxidant activity, while amino acids—especially L-theanine—produce a gentle sweetness and promote an unusual state of relaxed alertness.

Both beverages contain caffeine, and the caffeine molecule is chemically identical whether it comes from tea or coffee. The difference lies not in the molecule but in its company. A typical cup of tea contains less caffeine than a cup of coffee and also provides L-theanine, an amino acid found almost exclusively in tea. Together with tea’s naturally occurring polyphenols, L-theanine appears to modulate the subjective effects of caffeine, promoting a state of calm alertness rather than intense stimulation. Many tea drinkers, therefore, experience a steadier, more sustained wakefulness, without the pronounced surge—and, for some, the subsequent slump—that often follows a strong cup of coffee. Tea does not so much propel the mind as gently prepare it: awake, attentive and yet unhurried. Perhaps that is why the act of drinking tea so easily becomes a small ceremony of reflection, opening a quiet space in which ordinary things begin to reveal their depth.

Reading Virginia Woolf taught me that the deepest truths often arrive disguised as the smallest moments. A room, a window, a flower in a vase, the quiet ceremony of making tea—such things do not interrupt life; they are life. I often think of her while waiting for tea leaves to unfurl in hot water. Their fragrance cannot be hurried; it asks only for stillness. Then, almost imperceptibly, the mind loosens its grip on the day’s clamour. Thoughts that had been jostling for attention drift apart like clouds after rain, and an inward silence begins to gather. My own ritual is equally simple. Every morning around seven, and again at four in the afternoon, I prepare a cup of strong black tea, briefly boiling the leaves in water while warming the milk separately before the two meet in the cup. I have long since abandoned sugar. If a guest happens to arrive—which is less frequent these days—I gladly brew another pot. For all its chemistry and ceremony, tea remains, above all, a companion: to thought when one is alone, and to conversation when one is not.

Perhaps that is why tea is more than a beverage; it is a way of inhabiting time. A cup demands neither urgency nor distraction. The warmth against the palms, the rising fragrance, the deepening colour, the first sip, and the lingering aftertaste gently draw the wandering mind back to the present moment. One cannot hurry good tea; it quietly teaches patience. For a few unhurried minutes, yesterday’s regrets and tomorrow’s anxieties surrender their hold. The mind returns to the only place where life is ever lived—the present. If there is any philosophy in my daily cup, it is simply this: happiness rarely arrives with fanfare. More often, it unfolds quietly, like the fragrance of freshly brewed tea.

MORE FROM THE BLOG

Beyond the Molecule

Beyond the Molecule

I recently visited PI Health Sciences Ltd. at Genome Valley, Hyderabad, at the invitation of my long-standing friend, Dr. S. Chandrasekhar, who joined the organisation as Chief Scientific Advisor after his superannuation as Secretary, Department of Science and...

Nataraja: Metallurgy in Motion

Nataraja: Metallurgy in Motion

Among the great images created by Indian civilisation, few possess the visual authority of the Chola Nataraja. Shiva dances within a circle of flame, one foot planted upon ignorance and the other lifted in liberating grace. His hair flies outward, his arms extend in...

Salt, Spice and Time

Salt, Spice and Time

Recently, I had the pleasure of attending a family dinner hosted by Vishal Arora, a young CEO and a friend of my son Amol. His wife’s parents were also present. Although they all come from New Delhi, they seemed to carry with them something of the city’s older...