Unto this last

by | Jun 15, 2023

Books are precious in the sense that they capture the authors’ thoughts and retain them even after their lives, and in changed times. Those books that remain popular even after decades are called classics; those that remain relevant even after the passage of centuries become scriptures. 

Confined to home on health grounds, reading books has been my lifeboat lest I am drawn into despair. Recently, I concluded reading Mahatma Gandhi’s autobiography, My Experiments with Truth, and discovered a new meaning of the word “Truth.” Gandhiji even called Truth God and said that if one wants to meet God, it can be done by living one’s truth – as simple as that. 

But then why don’t people do that? Instead of observing their minds and deciphering their feelings, they seek solutions in the world – rush to religious places and follow dogmatic habits. Instead of living the truth of their lives – facing the reality of the moment – there is a tendency to escape in imagination. Instead of fighting, they choose a flight to survive. But the real problem arrives when this avoidance of reality leads one to a false reality. 

Coming to the book of Gandhiji, it is a wonderful read. It is amazing how he has written about his errors and moral lapses, which we all have but hide. Gandhiji went to South Africa as a failed lawyer back home and faced terrible discrimination meted out to Asians and local Blacks there. Over the years, he developed a non-violent method of dealing with oppressive rulers and gained recognition and popularity in the process. When he relocated to India after spending 20 years in South Africa, inspired by Gopal Krishna Gokhale, he joined the Indian independence movement and took it to the masses. The rest is history.  

Gandhiji mentioned in his autobiography, a short book, Unto the Last, by English author John Ruskin (1819-1900), which formed his political ideology. It was given to him by Leon Polak, an Englishman living in South Africa. Gandhiji paraphrased this book in Gujarati and called the idea Sarvodaya (Well-being of All). The economic development of a nation must include the upliftment of the person at the lowest level in the societal hierarchy – the masses living at the bottom of the pyramid. So, after I finished reading Gandhiji’s book, I located Ruskin’s book on the Internet. 

Oh my God, what a treasure of wisdom it is! 

Ruskin opens the book with a parable mentioned in the Bible (John 20). A vineyard owner went to a market yard and hired some workers on a day’s wage of 1 penny. When he found many sitting there still not hired by anyone, he added a few more at noon, and even some more towards the evening. He paid everyone an equal wage of a penny at the end of the day. 

The workers hired in the morning protested as to why the latecomers received equal wages. The landlord asked them how it affected them. Ruskin added that it was no wonder Christ was betrayed for 30 silver coins by his disciple – “So they weighed for my price thirty pieces of silver.”

England in the days of Ruskin was going through the Industrial Revolution. Many factories had been created, filling the air with smoke and fumes and pouring industrial waste by exporting their products throughout the vast British Empire. Workers performed repetitious factory work under the worst of conditions, and their families lived in poverty and ill health in crowded slums. 

Ruskin’s mother taught young John to read the Bible from beginning to end and Ruskin could differentiate early in life between right and wrong behaviour, and righteous and immoral ways of living. While growing up, he found the social conditions of the world around him deplorable. Ruskin envisioned a better society in which commerce was conducted justly, workers were treated fairly, people lived fulfilled, happy lives, and clean air, water, and soil were recognized as essential to human life and protected from industrialism. Ruskin felt that the business elite must improve the conditions of the lower classes out of moral responsibility.

The book includes four essays. The first essay, titled The Roots of Honour, deals with employer-employee relations. Ruskin insists that the employer must deal honourably with the employees. Ruskin writes, “And as the captain of a ship is bound to be the last man to leave his ship in case of a wreck, and to share his last crust with the sailors in case of famine, so the manufacturer, in any commercial crisis or distress, is bound to take the suffering of it with his men.”

The second essay is titled The Veins of Wealth. Ruskin defines wealth as power over man and disagrees with the science of getting rich by forcing people to work at low wages and generating profits by trading. “The true veins of wealth are purple — and not in Rock, but in Flesh — perhaps even that the outcome and consummation of all wealth are in the production of as many full-breathed, bright-eyed, and happy-hearted human creatures as possible.”

The third essay, Qui Judicatis Terram (Who Judge on Earth), deals with the idea of justice. When men are treated and paid justly, we go from a society where the rich get richer and the poor get poorer to a society where everyone has a chance to rise in economic status. “Government and co-operation are in all things the Laws of Life; Anarchy and competition the Laws of Death.”

The fourth and last article, Ad Valorem (According to Value), defines value, wealth, pricing, and production differently than political economists. According to Ruskin, value is that which leads to or sustains life. “A horse is useless, and therefore unsaleable, if no one can ride, — a sword, if no one can strike, and meat, if no one can eat. Thus, every material utility depends on its relative human capacity.”

Ruskin then summarises his economic thinking as an axiom, “THERE IS NO WEALTH BUT LIFE. Life includes all its powers of love, joy, and admiration. That country is the richest which nourishes the greatest number of noble and happy human beings; that man is richest who, having perfected the functions of his own life to the utmost, has also the widest helpful influence, both personal and using his possessions, over the lives of others.”

Ruskin wants political economists to focus on the type of products produced by a society, how widely these things are distributed to the populace, and how well people use them. Most crucially, he sees a true science political economy and true merchant and manufacturer company as producing a nation of healthy, engaged employees who live meaningful, joyful lives. For Ruskin, “That country is the richest which nourishes the greatest number of noble and happy human beings.”

Mahatma Gandhi might not have been followed by Indians in their lifestyles. But he has certainly not been forgotten. The picture of Mahatma Gandhi adorns the Indian currency. He is revered as the Father of the Indian Nation and with all our defects, there is an awareness about the treatment given to the poor in modern India. When I say this, I factor in the vastness of my nation and there may be pockets of darkness. Awareness towards the rights of the poor is fundamental. Treat the poor around you with respect and deal with them kindly.

India had a glorious culture of charitable hospitals and educational institutions. There has been a drift and it must be corrected. There are more than 150 billionaires in India, said to be the third-highest number in the world. Few of them are quite active in their social service. But if each one came forward to establish an autonomous and self-sustained world-class institution in public service – education, healthcare, law, whatever, adopting the basic civic amenities of a town in the process, we would have achieved something where most other countries have failed. 

MORE FROM THE BLOG

Look far ahead

Look far ahead

Since last month, I have been reading a rather scholarly book, The Book of Why, written by Israeli-American computer scientist Judea Pearl with Dana Mackenzie. The book deals with the often elusive relationship between cause and effect…

The Mystical Language of Numbers

The Mystical Language of Numbers

Is there an occult, divine or mystical relationship between a number and one or more coinciding events? In ancient Greece, Pythagoras propagated the idea that reality at the deepest level is essentially mathematical. He and many after him believed that a system of principles existed behind numbers…

A Moment of Civilisational Pride

A Moment of Civilisational Pride

I was born in 1955 in independent India. When I look back today, without hesitation, the best moment in public life I witnessed is the construction of a grand temple and the consecration of the idol of Shri Rama Lalla in Ayodhya on January 22, 2024…

12 Comments

  1. Dear Sir, Thank you once again for an enlightening blog. The prosperity and richness of the nation can be seen from the poorest of the poor being treated by society and the Government. Every effort has to improve the life of the last person in the lowest rung. But the present trend is disturbing and not in the best interest of the poor and it is more for political gain. The status or the standard of living will improve only when the person earns money through his effort.

    Anything that comes free is short-lived and makes one lazy. His progress becomes stunted. But the political class is more interested in its victory and progress. This is a dangerous trend, irrespective of which political dispensation indulges in it. But being an optimist I strongly believe we will progress and reach the stage of VISHWA GURU which we rightfully were. Thank you once again for a thought-provoking piece of literature

  2. Respected Sir, you raised a very important issue. Few rich people live surrounded by the crowds of the poor. But instead of concern, we see more indifference and even hardness of heart in them.

    It is fashionable to talk about poverty in numbers – poverty line and $2 a day. As I see it, poverty also encompasses low levels of health and education, poor access to clean water and sanitation, inadequate physical security, lack of voice, and insufficient capacity and opportunity to better one’s life.

    When a talented child is denied good education, a woman is not treated properly and becomes disabled in the process, and old people suffer from cataracts just because they cannot afford an operation, they are all suffering from poverty. By direct transfer of whatever money is in poor people’s accounts and giving free rations, nothing much is going to change.

  3. Equality in the social setup can only be achieved by bridging the gap between the haves and the have-nots. This gap has existed since time immemorial due to the interest and benefit of some upper-class, wealthy people.

    Many wise and learned visionaries have tried to create awareness among the masses, but all that was futile.
    If we look around us, everywhere the chasm between the classes (rich) and the masses(poor) is widening more and more. There is a feeling of discontentment among the masses.

    Thinkers and motivators like John Ruskin, and Gandhiji, dreamt of a just society where all needs of the population would be fulfilled, where all resources are equally distributed among the people. Their vision of a society where people are contented and happy sadly remains unfulfilled.

    We can only hope that maybe someday our future generations will grow up with this awareness and work together towards this goal. Let’s hope for the best.

    Thank you Tiwari Ji for such an enlightening blog.

  4. The book which guided Gandhiji for his freedom movement and upliftment of poor particularly the dalits, should be a must read. I personally haven’t, but definitely willing to read it now after reading such a beautifully put up blog. On a lighter note, I wish to encroach your library some day. Haha!!

  5. Great article bhai saab.
    We need another Ruskin revolution in today’s ruthless times.
    Alas, civilisational conscience awakens when we are about to drown in a big storm.

  6. arun this piece is among your best blogs. I enjoyed and enlightened reading it.

  7. दारिद्र्यं नमस्तुभ्यं, त्वत्प्रसादादभूत् सिद्धम्.
    पश्याम्यहं जगत्सर्वं, न तु मां पश्यति जगत्त्रय:।

    दरिद्रता, मैं तुझे नमस्कार करता हूं, तेरी कृपा से यह सिद्ध हुई।
    मैं सारे संसार को देखता हूँ, पर तीनों लोक मुझे नहीं देखते।

    हर गरीब इसलिए व्यक्तित्व विहीन होता जाता है, क्योंकि उसके पास व्यक्तित्व विकास के साधन नहीं होते। हर अमीर इसलिए व्यक्तित्व विहीनहोता जाता है, क्योंकि उसे बिना श्रम और सृजन के समाज में सम्मान पाने का आधार मिल जाता है।

  8. Thank you Prof Arun Sir for this enlightening write up.

  9. Dear Sir, I believe 30% of the Indian population do not want to do anything in life, they want everything free of cost, whatever you do for their future goodness they are not interested. hey just need free food and lots of rest in life watching Bollywood masala movies. Few % of special people are on a mission to achieve their religious agenda to get a haven afterlife. The rest of the population is doing routine work and just living life without any purpose, they don’t even bother to do their primary responsibilities for the nation like casting the vote.

    However, still I believe in the 2% of the population who are working for the nation and willing to help and uplift the whole population and the nation as a developed by 2030, let’s see where we go after 2024.

  10. Before reading this ‘ Unto this last’ blog by Respected Prof. Arun Tiwari Jee, I was listening to a post on WhatsApp. The person was saying that the ‘Brahman’ is a person who devotes his life to reading, understanding, finding ways and means, teaching and preaching to people, the issues crippling society.

    I find the same person in the blog of Sree Arun Tiwari Jee. He took the issues Mahatma Gandhi and Mr John Ruskin raised in their writings. The issues of equality. Responsibilities of rich people for poor. It should also be reminded that the poor, having the facilities for their upliftment, should not become addicted to that but rather try to become self-reliant.

    Tiwari Jee has been kind in writing this article and raising moral-social issues and, deserves the title ‘Brahman Sree Arun Tiwari. I pray to GOD to give him health, wealth and power to continue his ‘Brahmanatva’

  11. Dear Prof

    A very good reading piece of work, thanks!

    A man is born naked and is buried naked. Whatever material accumulation is gathered along the way, none of it goes down the grave with him. This writing and the Ruskin’s work (Unto this last) underscore the phenomenon of chasing after “vanity of vanities” .

  12. Very interesting. Loved the gist of all four essays from John Ruskin’s book. Also, had same feelings on reading Gandhiji’s My Experiments with Truth. How humbly he goes forward and shares not just positives & successes but shortcomings & failures as well. At some point in his life, did it seem like he prioritized anchoring on tactical non-violence more over anchoring on real truth? Also, this blog reminded me again of Swami Vivekananda on his push for Daridra Narayana Bhava and self reliance at national level for global good.

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Share This